Originally Posted by
Mesotech
I only own one "tweed" amp, the 5e3 clone from Weber, and I really do like it, but it is not suited for all styles of music. Though, there are styles of music where it excels, and more often than not, those styles don't require bleeding ears to be appreciated.
I also have a Boogie MkII combo, but it's more like a souped up bassman than anything like a modern Boogie. The other guitar player in my band uses a Boogie Dual Rectumfrier, and while it is high gain and has a nice smooth sound, it lacks the definition to cut through the mix on leads. Either one of my Marshalls blow it away in that respect. If it were up to me, I'd classify the Boogie Dual Rec as a rhythm only amp because it seems to fill the sonic spaces nicely. It simply doesn't have the balls to push past a Marshall when needed.
Now the Marshalls I have at my disposal are both mean machines. The JCM2000 DSL 100 has a great cut to it, but sounds pretty pathetic on its own. It sits perfectly in a band situation though, not muddying the water for the other instruments. The new JVM 410h that I have takes over where the DSL 100 leaves off in terms of high gain, but still cuts through the mix like only a Marshall can. It still sounds anemic on its own, but sits in the sonic mix right where it should. Knock it down into one of the more vintage channels and it'll punch like a Plexi, plus channel 1 is even voiced like a Fender and it gets some very convincing Twin tones. And loud? Yes, very. Loud enough to cause a drummer (or anyone else) to not be able to hear his drums or cymbals. I've only pushed it that far once, just to see how loud it'll get. Way TOO loud.
My Ampeg VL1002 (Lee Jackson designed) sits between the JCM 2000 and the JVM 410h in terms of gain, but it's still more gain than most can tolerate for extended periods of time. Better cleans than any Boogie Dual or Triple Rec can dream of, but no where near a Fender clean. The EQ on this amp allows selections between a Fender, Marshall, and Boogie tone stack, as well as two additional configurations that are unique to the amp. When I use the amp, I put it in the Marshall mode and pretend it's a souped up JCM 2000.
That's it for my "high gain" weapons. I tend to lean more towards the Fender Blackface and vintage Marshall tones in way of personal preference. For the stuff I "like" to play, I don't need all that stinkin gain, but I don't always play just what I like.
My current workhorse amp is the JVM because it covers a lot of ground (like having 12 amps in 1 head). It has a line out that I can run direct to the board instead of using a mic (meaning I can adjust the master volumes (2 of them) to set my stage volume without affecting the sound going to the board).
Even still, I use nearly all of my amps in different contexts because they each have unique qualities. That's why all amps are different to begin with. The Tweeds do their thing, and that's that. If "that thing" ain't "your thing" then it's not the right amp for you. Nothing wrong with that.