I was reading Ron Ashton's obit in today's New York Times. They mentioned that, for the Stooges "Raw Power" LP, James Williamson took over guitar duties and Ashton was "demoted" to bass. Wouldn't you think that there's a better choice of words?
Printable View
I was reading Ron Ashton's obit in today's New York Times. They mentioned that, for the Stooges "Raw Power" LP, James Williamson took over guitar duties and Ashton was "demoted" to bass. Wouldn't you think that there's a better choice of words?
Reminds me of a quote attributed to Frank Zappa regarding Rock n Roll journalism..
"People who can't talk being interviewed by people who can't write for an audience who can't read".
I read the same article. A particularly lame choice of words. At least they got most of the history right.
Yeah, that sucks. I used to think that way. I've always owned a bass, but until we formed Ms. Behavin' I'd never played bass in a band. When I first started with the new band I was thinking that playing bass was a "demotion" but we really wanted to keep this band a 4 piece and my buddy Mike is playing guitar so I figured I'd give it a try. It's been fun and it's been a real learning experience. When I get back on my guitars, they feel small and I feel faster and more accurate.
I've also since learned that the bass player is the "engine" of the band. I finally figured it out when I watched people dancing to my "pulse"! I've never been more tight with a drummer either. It's critical as a bass player. I never knew how tough it really was to play bass correctly. I don't really feel worthy of the title of "bass player". I still feel like a "guitar player playing bass". I've realized that I definitely have a "style" though. I've brought a lot of my own style to the bass and I like what I'm doing...it's unique. Purists I'm sure will criticize, but this is Rock and Roll and the only rule to me is that there are no rules! This experience has been a real eye-opener for me and it definitely wasn't a demotion.
Keef - in talking about the then-new Rolling Stones bassist Darryl Jones - used the concept of engine, also to describe the bass player. And he further went on to say that Darryl's playing made Charlie 'happy'.
IMHO, there is nothing like having a smokin' bass player in your band. He's the glue between the rhythmic and the harmonic aspects of a song.
By the way, if you want to get away from sounding like a guitarist playing bass, get yourself a copy of the Motown box set and try to cop some of Jamerson's licks. I say 'try' because there's some stuff on those cuts that are superhuman.
the drummer is the Ties, the Bass the Rails......
Thats how the railroad gets where its going, through some pretty interesting terrain!
Ya gatta love them hills, valleys and bridges along the way - and how bout that weather!?!?!
Yeah - he wassn't demoted to bass, he was given the opportunity to do something not everyone can do and he done it well!
I've been demoted too. :(
I envy good bass players. They get all the gigs.
You can always tell a guitar player who feels he's been 'demoted' to bass. Crappy parts with minor thirds where majors belong. And they don't know the difference.
In an old interview witth Paul McCartney he said he didn't want to play bass but no one else was going to do it. Fortunately he found a way to play it to make himself happy and rewrite the bassplayer rule book.
I got promoted from triangle.......
There are thousands of good guitarists
but only a handfull of Great bassists,
I have been a guitarist all my life, but as a guitarist
i wasnt always in the best band, but i could always
get into the "Best" bands in a town as a bassist.
it was a good trade off
Like with Paul McCartney, you put your guitar
chops knowlege to your bass playing and you
become a memorable bassist
I recently started focusing on bass rather than guitar, and it's been the most fun I've had musically in a long time.
I'd call it a promotion. :D
Coldsteel, I agree about Macca - one of my 2 or 3 favorite bassists - but he brought a tremendous musicality and amazing harmonically sophisticated ears to the mix. Noel Redding, on the other hand...ugh. There was a frustrated guitarist playing bass, to be sure...
I play guitar and bass about 50/50 and I wouldn't have it any other way. And as Kap points out, there's usually a call for bass players.
I worship the Guitar and respect the Bass. Most Guitar players can't play Bass but think they can. I realized this many years ago when I became "The Bass Player" in a band. Took a while to master it and it was a real study.
Nowadays my Fender Jazz bass collects dust but every now and then I get a call to sub in on a Bass. I then need to re-learn and study the Bass again prior to the Gig so I plop on "BB King Live at Cooke County Jail" and Jam on that a while. It seems to give me the "Be the Bass Player" attitude and gets rid of the rust. I can't just pick up a Bass and do it. Playing Bass ain't just that simple.
i played bass 20 years, to me its like riding a bike.
Once I heard James Jamerson I figured it was pointless for me to go much farther wth bass.
I rode a bike for 20 years and struggle to play bass. :laughing: :doh
Although I've been concentrating on guitar for the past 10 years my first musical love is the bass, of which I started out on. Gigged for years as a bass player and loved every minute of it.
Still love playing bass and would still be most comfortable in a gigging situation as a bass player, if I ever chose to do so again.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9KC7uhMY9s
Singer wasn't too bad either... ;-)
I watched my best friend start and become a really great bass player.
I started when I was 8, my friend when he was 14.
When I left the top 40 band I was working in at 15 he and I found a drummer and started our own band. (1975) We played as a power trio for about 6 years.
My bass player friend started out with a Fender, like a squire or something and a small fender bass combo. Then a Ric into a some bigger stack, then to an Alembic into stereo peavy heads, with a collection of different size speakers. Can't recall exactly, but it was huge and loud!
He and the drummer, who later went on to tour with some big names could give me a platform to ride that was heaven. Together they could take a guitar solo and let me push it and push it until it just about went off the rails.
My friend was always so humble, he'd let me get out there and sing and play my brains out like a maniac and he'd be back there making me look good.
He knew just what he and the drummer were doing to the song and how they were working with what I was doing..
A really good rock bass player is a special person, I think that's why many guitar players who try to play bass get frustrated. It's not just playing the instrument, it's providing what's called for in that spot, hard to put into words.
I've got the deepest respect for bass players.
- HR
I like playing bass and guitar, there is no hierarchy in music.
Been playing both guitar and bass for 42 years,love playing bass with a good Bill Wyman/Ringo/Stan Lynch type drummer.
The older I get the simpler and tighter I want music to be.
EXACTLY!
not to sound like an A hole, but i get compliments on my bass playing. i just tell them i'm from the dusty hill school of bass playing. lay it down fat!
I'm certain that there are myopic anal-retentives who'd regard being switched from guitar to bass as a "demotion" but I am envious of those players who are blessed with the versatility to switch between instruments (gitts, bass, keys, horns, whatever).
My brother in Sacramento is a bassist and like me, started out on guitar. I gave him a '66 P-Bass before I went overseas in 1970 -- he took to it like Bill Clinton at an unchaperoned Girl Scout jamboree and never looked back. He's probably a better bassist than I am a guitarist. And his ten-megaton bass rigs are rivaled by few on the west coast......his matched pair of vintage Acoustic 370s generate a 10.5 seismic event on the Richter scale, bouncing the rubble from Chico to Fresno. Likewise his vintage Sunn Coliseums can cause congential birth defects through six or seven generations.
"Demoted"? Tom doesn't see it that way. And neither do I.
I have a bass, I really should play it more. Problem is, the gang that comes over all are better bass players.. come to think of it.. there are better guitarist... and vocalists... and drummers...
even with all my inadequacies I have fun and that is why we do it - for over 14 years.
Yes, I have improved.
the who, the Jam, double trouble, blues traveler, all has bass players I wish I could emulate..
I hear ya there. I've gotten so locked in to "bass thinking" that guitar is just not doing it much for me anymore -- and I've lost some chops there. But I've gained a bunch more, so it evens out, I guess.
And anyone who thinks of playing bass as a demotion needs to listen closely to James Jamerson, or Bob Babbit, or Lee Sklar, or... or... there'a a lot, actually. Including this gal:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wK03p...eature=related
And here she is with Mr. Beck:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIFFR...eature=related
Demotion? Never.
I play guitar because I'm a failed bass player.
True.
As a guitar player, I play almost every weekend. The gigs vary from real dives to big clubs. As a bass player (and not a real good one either), I have played some of the best venues around and won 2 battle of the bands contests. The money was right and easy. There are a million great guitar players. There are usually only a handful of good bassists. Playing bass part time has helped my guitar playing.
Concert410 is on to something (if one can play bass well--not like guitarist who happens to be playing bass)
I got hooked up with Sara Petite and the Sugardaddies as a bass player. I moved to guitar when the incumbent quit.
Chicks dance to what the bass is playing. :dude
that, and the kick drum.
Clapton is a great blues guitarist when he plays with regular good bass players. When he played with Jack Bruce, he changed music forever. Same with Miles Davis and Michael Henderson. Same with John Lennon and Paul McCartney.
And then there are the great bassists/composers: Willie Dixon, Sting, etc. And of course, Beethoven without his basses would be a mild variant of chamber music...
Demotion, my (b)ass.
John
PS, one note from my Spector NSJH5 through my SWR with the 15" reflex cabinet will shake your soul.
:dude
I'm very aware of how important bass is, and for a while was actually focusing quite a bit on bass playing--I even thought about music from that prespective.
I now own two quality Basses:
http://members.cox.net/wilko2/fender/p_green.jpg
http://photos-f.ak.fbcdn.net/photos-...73_6606282.jpg
MMmmmm Mmmmmm mmmmm!
I LOVE that Rickenbacker 4001, wish i could
afford one. Had a couple in the past, was
an idiot ever trading them in.